Charles C. Cook, Presbyterian missionary to the Pima Indians of Arizona

The first Protestant missionary to the Pima Indians was Chares C. Cook. Reverend Cook resided among the Pima for 15 years before the Pima began to understand and accept his message. All the Pima churches, including the one in which my wife and I worship, trace their beginning to this remarkable man. You can read about him here. His niece, Minnie Cook, wrote a book about him, Apostle to the Pima Indians.

Charles C. Cook

Charles Cook was born in Germany about 1843 and sailed for the United States prior to the Civil War. He served as a soldier for the Union, and was wounded in battle. After the war he applied to the Presbyterian Board of National Missions. The Board of National Missions had a simple mission: establishing Christian churches where there are none, “so that the Gentiles might glorify God for his mercy” (Romans 15:12).

Sheldon Jackson

This was pioneering work, the work of modern day apostles. Some missionaries, like Charles Cook, went to live on Indian reservations. Others, like Sheldon Jackson (1834-1909), established Sunday Schools among white settlers who were moving west. These Sunday Schools, fortunately, could not afford to pay a preacher, so they gathered strength from their own members and taught the Bible and worshipped on Sundays, recognizing the gift of teaching in one or another members. Sheldon Jackson kept moving westward until he had established more than 100 Sunday Schools and churches. He arrived in Alaska in 1877.

In 1958 the Presbyterian Church USA General Assembly voted to dissolve the Board of National Missions. The assumption since then is that “churches start churches.” But churches do not start churches among unreached peoples. A great sterility has begun. The Presbyterian church as a whole has become more white, less Hispanic, less African-American, less Native American, and, less representative of the great number of unreached peoples who live in America in 2025. Here is why.

Today, all Presbyterian mission efforts in the US are organized by Presbyterian presbyteries. A presbytery is a regional governing structure, made up of Presbyterian pastors and elders. There are 166 Presbyterian Church (USA) presbyteries. I am a retired member of the Grand Canyon Presbytery. Since I am a missionary to Muslims, the Presbyterian created a special nametag for me that read, “Serving without jurisdiction.” This is fine; but let the reader understand: the Presbytery is not organized to think about establishing churches among unreached peoples.

About that great sterility. Without a dedicated mission agency to concentrate on sending missionaries to the thousands of unreached Muslim peoples, Hindu peoples, and Asian peoples who are coming to America, the Presbyterian Church (USA) has zero opportunities to bring about what used to be known as the Great End of the Church: “The proclamation of the gospel for the salvation of all peoples.” “Mission” is still the word used to do what Presbyterians are doing these days, but it means something considerably less than it once did. The entire mission to unreached peoples in America is being carried out by specialized mission agencies. May they succeed in turning hearts to Christ, “that the Gentiles might glorify God for his mercy.”

Let us have a moment to consider the effects of this decision of the Presbyterian Church (USA) to dissolve its own mission agency:

  • There are far, far fewer Presbyterian churches among Spanish speakers than there were sixty years ago.
  • There are far, far fewer Presbyterian churches among African-Americans than there were sixty years ago.
  • All the wonderful Korean congregations which meet in Presbyterian buildings were established by missionaries with the Board of Foreign Missions in Korea. Unfortunately, the Board of Foreign Missions was also dissolved in 1958. This was beginning of the end of Presbyterian mission efforts among unreached peoples in Asia, Africa and the Middle East.
  • All the wonderful Arab churches which are housed in Presbyterian churches are not Arab Muslims; they are Arab Christians who have never been Muslim. Efforts to establish churches of Muslim background believers in America are being carried out by specialized mission agencies.

Conclusion. The theory that “churches start churches,” asserted these last sixty years, can now be examined. Six results can be proposed;

  1. Church leaders may indeed hive off some church members to establish a daughter church nearby, thus starting other churches. The members of a daughter church look very much like the church which birthed it.
  2. Churches do not start churches among unreached peoples. Establishing churches among unreached peoples is the specialty of bands of missionaries who pledge themselves to this certain task.
  3. Until 1958 the Presbyterian Church (USA) approved two governing structures: the Presbytery (for churches where they already exist) and a special mission agency, (The Board of National Missions), whose sole mission was to establish churches where they do not exist.
  4. The Holy Spirit is still sending missionaries like Sheldon Jackson and Charles C. Cook. They are joining special mission agencies which hold them accountable for the work of planting churches among unreached peoples.
  5. It may come about that Presbyterian Church (USA) might aspire to the mission that our Lord expressed when He said, “I have other sheep that are not of this fold; I must bring them also. They too must hear my voice and be gathered in” (John 10:14-16). The best future for the Presbyterian Church (USA), should such a mission be undertaken, is to partner with mission agencies that specialize in starting churches among unreached peoples.
  6. The idea that “churches start churches” is not only a problem in liberal and mainline denominations; it is a widely held assumption in evangelical churches as well.

As it was in the beginning, there are two structures of God’s redemptive mission, one administrating the church where it already exists; the other sending missionaries where there is no church. The highest mission priority is sending missionaries where there is no church, “so that the Gentiles might glorify God for his mercy.”