The Church in Early Irish Society

Irish Christians Established Two Administrative Structures, Allowing 1) Local Churches to Serve Irish Congregations and Enabling 2) Irish Monasteries to Send Missionaries to non-Christians in “the regions beyond.”

.“In this book,” Kathleen Hughes, “I have been particularly interested in how the early Irish church was organized.” This is a topic of considerble interest to us, as the Irish church established two structures of God’s redemptive mission: 1) the local church (for Sunday worship and nurture) and 2) monasteries (for the expansion of Christian mission to the “regions beyond”). The local church served a stable Christian population, while the monasteries were mobile, sending missionaries to non-Christian lands. Kathleen Hughes writes, “The old-type diocesan sees [church administrations] could not possibly have made any comparable expansion.[1]”

The monastic movement enabled Irish Christianity to escape the weakening effects of nominalism and worldliness that tend to encumber local churches in their second or third generation. Renewal comes to all when some Christians, faced with growing worldliness among the members, bind themselves to one another in committed communities. Most importantly, the abbots appointed bishops from among the members of the monasteries. These “evangelicals bishops” had high expectations of the members of the churches under their watch care. This is the Irish way that continually renewed Christianity for three centuries after it arrived to the island nation.

The Monastic Movement, Begun in Egypt, Gained a Great Following In Ireland. The desert version of monastic life, perfected in the wilderness of Egypt, had turned from the nominalism and worldliness which Christianity had acquired by its development in a world of urban civilization, material wealth and bureaucratic government. The men who sought solitude in the desert abandoned property. Monasticism meant a fresh start. It demanded a long period of ascetic discipline which culminated in contemplative experience. Difficult as this life was, many found its objects worth striving for. The men who attempted it believed that its attainable goal was a state of indescribable blessedness. The readers of the Life of the early hermit, Saint Antony, saw in him not a gloomy fanaticism, but a realization of the felicity for which they longed.[3]

It was the Egyptian ex-soldier Pachomius who revolutionized monasticism by introducing three entirely new elements—corporate life, obedience, and work. He organized fully resident communities under the direction of a superior, where a considerable part of every day was spent in productive work for the benefit of the monks and the world outside. His younger contemporary Basil of Cappadocia gave a summary of this. “If a man loves God,” Basil said, “he must love his brother also.” Basil built an almshouse and a hospital, and attached a school to his monastery. His sister, Macrina, turned the family residence into a convent for women and in times of famine went out to gather up the babies who had been abandoned at the roadside. His younger brother set out intending to lead a hermit’s life, but came across some helpless old people, so stayed near them, fishing and providing for them all. The combination of these two—the contemplative life and its social obligations—was to prove a truly creative element in western monasticism.[4]

How did did monasticism transfer itself three thousand miles from the eastern deserts to the coasts and highlands of the Celtic west?[5]

The First Missionaries. Christianity had arrived in Ireland before Patrick. Pope Celestine sent Palladius in 431 as first bishop to the Irish.[6] There can be no doubt that a church under Roman influence flourished in Galloway in the fifth and sixth centuries. The southern Picts had been converted before Patrick addressed his letter to Coroticus referring to the ‘apostate,’ that is, immoral Picts.[7] Patrick was a Briton from a partially Romanized area in the west of Wales. When he was sixteen, as he himself tells the story in his Confession, he was captured by a raiding party and carried off to Ireland, where he became a slave. “I did not know the Lord,” he writes. “He lifted me up from the deep mire.” That communion maintained him in a state of serenity and joy throughout the physical hardships of his task: “I felt no harm and there was no sloth in me, because the spirit within me was then fervent.” He spent six years in slavery, apparently without thought of escape, until one night in a dream there came to his ears the voice which then and later was to change the pattern of his life: “See, your ship is ready.” He fled his master, traveling about two hundred miles to where a merchant ship waited. He returned safely to his family, but then in a dream he was directed to return to Ireland.[8]

The Problem of Nominalism and Worldliness in the Sixth Century British Church. The problems which the author addresses are nominalism and worldliness in the British churches. “Gildas complains bitterly that unsuitable persons bought episcopal offices; they were worth buying. The bishops were well-to-do men who commanded prestige, and princes used their influence in the church to further political intrigues.”[9]

The conversion of the Irish under Patrick’s leadership is well-known and we will not cover it here. It should be emphasized that Patrick set about to establish the church under bishops. “Each bishop had a number of churches in his diocese in which he was expected to officiate on occasions. Clergy adopted Roman conventions of personal appearance by shaving their heads and wearing a tunic, so distinguishing themselves from the non-Christian population.”[10]

The Foundation of Monastic Paruchiae. Blincoe: What the author is saying at length is that the conversion of the Irish was not followed by a slow decay of nominalism and worldliness, as had been the case in Britain and elsewhere. For in Ireland the “making of disciples” was achieved in every generation with the founding of great numbers of monasteries. In this way, and for a hundred years, beginning in the second half of the sixth century, the Irish saved themselves from an oft-repeated descent into nominalism and worldiness. With the monastery as the school of Christ and the committed communities of troublesome brothers or sisters as the iron that sharpens iron, Christianity not only made disciples of the Irish, but sent Irish sons to Scotland, Britain and the mainland of Europe where they set in motion a revival by way of establishing ever more monasteries. In no other way could the Irish have saved themselves, and in this way only did the Irish “save civilization.” With this summary, we return to the author’s narrative.

Author: The second half of the sixth century saw the foundation of the great monastic paruchiae, or expansion as certain monasteries became concentrated on establishing daughter monasteries. Before the century was out, Columcille had founded Derry, Durrow and Iona, Comgall had established Bangor, and Columbanus had left the schools of Bangor for the Continent, where, before his death in 615, he had set up monastic houses at Annegray, Luxeuil, and Bobbio. These are only a few of the monasteries founded during the late sixth and early seventh centuries. The first missionaries had aimed to preach the gospel to the heathen laity: the monastic founders were primarily concerned to build up the individual Christian into the perfect man.[11]

The writings of Columbanus present the compelling ideas of one such monastic founder. In the violence and insecurity of the Merovingian era, Columbanus summoned each of his disciples to found his character on the rock of Christ. The way was by the abandonment of self, for the asceticism which is Columbanus’ dominating theme is of the mind and the will, as well as of the body. To mortify the flesh alone is to dig outside and on one’s boundaries, leaving his land within untilled. We must die to ourselves, that is, to our will, in order to live for Christ. For Columbanus there was no place for compromise or moderation. The Christian life must be constant warfare against man’s will. To win the inner battle, the monk must live thus:

Let him not do as he wishes, let him eat what he is bidden, keep as much as he has received, complete the task of his work, but subject to whom he does not like. Let him come weary to his bed, and let him be forced to rise while his sleep is not yet finished. Let him keep silence when he has suffered wrong. Let him fear the superior of his community as a lord, love him as a father, and believe that whatever he commands Is healthful for him.[12]

The strict rule of Columbanus should be put alongside his own care for his community, and the mystical experience of love to which his asceticism was directed. Moreover, the society which held his community was not conducive to gentleness; he called men out of the violence of Merovingian Gaul to join others in this “way to life.”[13] The ascetic life was arduous, but the Christian was sustained by Bible study and love for God; and as everyone knows, “love, even while it is all the trouble in the world, is yet no trouble.” Great monastic founders called men, with burning eloquence, to learn the hidden mysteries of God:

Lord, grant me, I pray in the name of Jesus Christ Thy Son, my God, that love which shall never fail, so that my lamp may feel Thy kindling touch and know no quenching. Enrich my lantern with Thy light, that constantly I may see, observe, desire Thee only, and loving Thee only, may behold, and before Thee my lamp may ever shine and burn. Amen.[14]

Columbanus set up his hermitage at Annegray in the rocky wilderness of the Vosges, where he and his brethren lived on herbs, wild apples, even tree bark. He attracted new disciples, and before long received endowments. The houses founded by him and his disciples in particular Luxeuil, St. Gall, and Bobbio, became important and well-established monasteries.[15]

Two Systems of Governance: Local Church and Monastic Communities. The system of monastic government was thus markedly difference from the local church system. “The monastic paruchia had great powers of expansion: however far the monks travelled, they were still part of the family. Thus, the new monasticism was able to use the desire for wandering which was still alive in a people who had been, with tribal memory, on the move.”[16] We need to know when and why monastic paruchia developed, what were their relations with the old episcopal dioceses, and what was the effect of their development upon the Celtic church.[17]

What the Historical Records Tell Us. The Annals name twenty-eight Irish clerics in the period before the great plague which began in 549: of these, twenty-five are bishops, one an abbot, and two are unidentified in rank. Between 549 and 600 thirty-three men are named, of whom thirteen are bishops, seventeen abbots or priests, and three unidentified. In the period 601-64 there are more names, ninety-seven in all. The ecclesiastical rank of twenty-five of these cannot be identified; but of the remainder, twenty-four are bishops and forty-eight are abbots. Thus, the annals clearly show an overwhelming preponderance of bishops before 549. The second half of the sixth century is the period of change, with almost as many bishops as there are abbots mentioned, and from the seventh century onward the preponderance of abbots is decisive.[18]

A historical record, the Life of Samson, tells how a certain learned and distinguished Irishmen, on their way back from Rome, called on a  British saint named Samson, who returned with them to Ireland. Before starting off, Samson obtained his [British] bishop’s sanction. Samson was at this time an abbot. This shows that the abbot in Britain was still under his bishop’s authority.[19] This was not the case in Ireland. “In the Irish church, bishops had no powers of jurisdiction over the abbots.”[20]

The old bishopric was limited to a narrow territorial area, almost certainly to the boundaries occupied by the population-group in which the bishop was resident. The monastic paruchia, on the other hand, might keep expanding, for land might be offered to the patron saint (or his heirs) anywhere in the Celtic areas, and even in England and on the Continent. [By contrast] the abbots were thus overlords of a number of monasteries with their tenants, buildings and lands.[21] The paruchia of Comgall of Bangor made new foundations across the Irish Sea: Comgall had been a friend of Columcille. In 673 Mael-ruba of Bangor, then a young man of thirty, founded a church at Applecross, on the Scottish mainland. His disciples travelled by sea along the coasts and islands to the east. Another Irishman named Fursey, this time in episcopal orders, left Ireland and founded a monastery in Cnobheresburg in East Anglia (probably within the massive late Roman fortification at Burgh Caste). He then proceeded to the Continent, leaving his brother Foílleán at Cnobheresburg, and settled at Lagny on the Marne to the east of Paris. Nivelles, ruled by an abbess, was added to his paruchia, and his brother Foílleán, who succeeded him, founded Fosse near Namur. The old-type diocesan sees (governments) could not possibly have made any comparable expansion.[22]


[1] Kathleen Hughes, The Church in Early Irish Society (Ithaca, N.Y.,: Cornell University Press, 1966). 81-82

[2] Ibid. 10-11

[3] Ibid. 12-13

[4] Ibid. 14-15

[5] Ibid. 15-16

[6] Ibid. 32

[7] Ibid. 28

[8] Ibid. 30

[9] Ibid. 40

[10] Ibid. 50

[11] Ibid. 57

[12] Ibid. 58

[13] Ibid. 58

[14] Ibid. 74

[15] Ibid. 92

[16] Ibid. 78

[17] Ibid. 64

[18] Ibid. 65

[19] Ibid. 72-73

[20] Ibid. 108

[21] Ibid. 81

[22] Ibid. 81-82