In 1219 Francis of Assisi Crossed No Man’s Land to Meet the Sultan

In 1219, during the Fifth Crusade, Francis and one other Christian brother crossed no man’s land to seek an audience with Sultan Malik al-Kamil at Damietta in Egypt. Francis’ biographer, Celano, describes how Francis first tried to dissuade the Crusaders from fighting (and predicted failure, because the Crusade army was not led by the Spirit of God but by the insolence of men).[1] Francis, upon giving up on preaching to the Crusaders, crossed no man’s land, where he was taken captive and treated roughly. In fact, Francis was hoping for a martyr’s crown. However, the Sultan received him as a guest and gave Francis permission to speak. Celano records that Francis preached Jesus Christ, the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world. This went on for some days. Francis was puzzled that his words did not have their desired effect, and for this reason Francis conceived of the idea of the “not yet” of God:
That Muslims were not ready to convert indicated to Francis that the time had not yet come. His disciples would have to be patient, then, and ready to serve in humbleness of spirit, in the spirit of ‘minoritas’ and submission (I Peter 3:15). At the same time, we Franciscans [today] are convinced that God is at work. The Holy Spirit is ahead of us, and many things happen altogether outside or apart from our activity. The plan of God moves ahead independent of us.[2]
The other mission God had given Francis, repairing His Church, also figured in Francis’ opinion of how the Christians ought to encounter Muslims:
Francis tried in his gentle yet firm way to convert the attitudes of the Church with regard to Islam. He wished the Church to be among the Muslims as a poor and serving Church, powerless, identifying itself with the most marginalized persons.[3]
The Franciscan “way of the Lord” is the refusal of power. And this seems to me to be the way of Christ when he was arrested and brought before Pontius Pilate. The Franciscans make a vow to refuse power, to be “minor” in a wicked world where, proud persons desire to be “major.” The Crusades were “major”; the Franciscan way is “minor.”
We have arrived at the 800th anniversary of the death of Francis, in 1226. The reader will remember the prayer of Saint Francis, “Lord, Make Me an Instrument of Thy Peace.” It has been set to music; you can hear the music here (a brilliant soprano) or here (a choral performance). The sheet music is available for purchase here.
We pray that the day of “not yet” has passed, and that for millions of Muslims, now is the day of salvation. Now is the time to hear God’s voice and go to the Muslim world as missionaries.
[1] Father Mel Brady Secretary General of the Franciscans (Order of Friars Minor), “Franciscan Mission among Muslims, on the Occasion of the 8th Centenary of Francis’ Birth,” (Assisi, Italy 1982).
[2] Ibid.
[3] Ibid.


Amen! From Albania. Pray because the King’s Assembly is into presence EV and the dominant I religion is into Major as it always has been. The I here are resurging slowly but surely.
Mark Kreitzer
St. Francis Assisi is an historical hero, an exemplary saint among the saints of all time. Thanks Bob for this timely piece. We pray for many more like him in these evil days in which we live
Bob, How encouraging and timely for this piece on St. Francis. Yes, I think the “minor” way always works better, whether it’s Muslims or anyone else. Sadly, our current bombing campaign in Iran is likely to give the opposite message; it’s more like a 21st Century Crusade. Happily, our pastor is in Assisi this week for the 800th anniversary of Francis’ passing. We are following his posts on Facebook with joy.
Unfortunately the Franciscans (or at least some of them) lost there way in regards to refusing power as they were the primary religious order that accompanied the Conquistadors in their brutal colonization of the America by Spain (1492–1600s).
Franciscan friars served as the essential religious, cultural, and administrative arm of the Spanish conquest, arriving early 1523 to forcibly convert indigenous populations, destroy native religious structures, and impose European culture. While they often sought to protect indigenous people from brutal exploitation, their missions facilitated forced labor and they were frequently complicit in brutal exploitation. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_missions_in_the_Americas#:~:text=Franciscan%20missionaries%20were%20the%20first,his%20native%20brothers%20and%20sisters.