Starting New Ministries and Persuading Local Churches to Validate Them. Stories from Toronto and Salem.

A Story of the Catholic Church Toronto, and How a Protestant Church in Oregon is Leading the Way

The Catholic Church, sometimes characterized as rigid and hierarchical, has proven sufficiently flexible to encourage its members to begin hundreds of voluntary societies that are doing good works in the Toronto area. None of these voluntary ministries started in the office or the bishop or priests; they were established by the people in the pews. Peter Wyatt, Catholic professor of mission at Emmanuel College in Toronto, explains the relationship between the bishop and religious orders in Toronto:

One of the auxiliary bishops has the task of keeping track of these various ministry groups. One of the reasons he does so is simply to know what kinds of ministry and activity these groups are doing. The hierarchy is not interested prima facie in controlling them. It simply wants to know what ministry is going on in the name of the Catholic Church in the local diocese. An advantage of knowing what the groups are doing is that they can be aware of each other and perhaps can pool their resources.[1]

The number of Catholic religious societies that the bishop of Toronto is keeping track of, John Pellowe reports, is “between 265 and 280.” Examples of ministries operated by volunteers in the Toronto area:  Catholic Children’s Aid Society of Toronto, and Saint Vincent de Paul Toronto.

The bishop regulates dozens and dozens of voluntary ministries in his area, but he does not administrate any of these ministries. This is the genius of the Catholic model. The Catholic church regulates, but does not initiate or administrate ministries that its members begin. If ministries are in good standing doctrinally, and if they report annually, the bishop validates their ministries. However, the bishop can also invalidate any ministry that runs afoul of the doctrines or mission of the church. Peter Wyatt cites an occasion when the bishop issued a statement disassociating his office from one ministry, the Army of Mary, because it “no longer represents itself as truly Catholic” since “its leaders teach a doctrine that is contrary to that of the Catholic Church” on fundamental points.[2]

In this “enviable Catholic synthesis” we see a pattern for Protestants. Protestant pastors and church boards should shepherd their flocks by examining the ministries that their members are supporting, and issue a commendation or a warning that will guide their members in their giving and support for local or global engagement.

Shepherd the flock: A commendable example from a church in Salem, Oregon.

I met new friends in Salem, Oregon recently. I listened to them describe three mighty fine mission agencies that are changing the world. All three of these missions have been assessed and validated by the church in Salem I was attending, called the Morning Star Church. Before Sunday worship service began, the screen in front directed the congregation to support these ministries. I appreciate the church leaders for validating the ministries that its members are involved in. Here is what I suggest for my readers:

  1. Ask the elders of your church to assess up to ten ministries that your members are involved in.
  2. Suggest that the elders a) validate these ministries and b) provide a link on the church website directly to the ministry.
  3. Encourage members to support these ministries financially. No need to run the expenses through the church accounting office.

Two kinds of structures comprise God’s redeeming mission: The congregation is first; it meets for worship and for learning and faith building. The second is the hundreds of mission agencies that members of your congregation support. Thus, the church assembles for worship, and dismisses the congregation to go into the world to do God’s mission. (Can you see the word “mission” in the important word “dismiss?”) The elders should “shepherd the flock” by validating these ministries (or, in case of doubt that the ministries should be validated, warning the congregation not to support a particular ministry). Pastors: shepherd the flock. Guide your congregation in the process of validating and endorsing certain mission agencies.

Morning Star Church in Salem has validated and endorsed three ministries.

1. Salem for Refugees The foreigner who sojourns with you shall be to you as the native among you, and you shall love the foreigner as yourself. Leviticus 19:34

2. Baraka Refugee Legal Services. “Our Mission: Showing Christ’s love by providing high quality, low-cost immigration legal services in the Willamette Valley.” Our Vision: Every person in the Willamette Valley has access to the immigration legal services they need to thrive and contribute to the community.

3. Salem Angels –The Foster Care Community “Our mission: walking alongside children, youth, and families in the foster care community by offering consistent support through intentional giving, relationship building, and mentorship.” Watch this video, “Why so many foster care givers burn out.” Eight minutes.

As it was in the beginning, two kinds of structures make up God’s redemptive mission.

I am trying to give a brighter day to Pastor Lewis whose hands are pressed against his furrowed brow. “If only the church were organized right,” he says, “we would not need the parachurch agencies.” The rapprochement I desire is this: pastors asks the members of their congregation to submit names of mission agencies which church members support. The church board examines these mission agencies and decides whether to validate these ministries. If the church validates a ministry, it should promotes the ministry on the church website and in the worship hour. The church website provides a direct link to them. Donations to these specialized ministries need not be routed through the church treasury. Thus, church leaders validate, but do not initiate or administrate, the several ministries their members are involved with. The church website provides a link to these ministries. No need to run the expenses through the church accounting office. Do this, pastors, and you will shepherd your flocks.


[1] John Pellowe, “Leading Ministries into Christian Community: A Practical Theology for Church-Agency Relations” (D. Min. Dissertation, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, 2008). 313.

[2] Ibid. 457.