What is “Desired Symbiosis?”
Ralph D. Winter used the term symbiosis in his article, “The Two Structures of God’s Redemptive Mission.”
Ralph D. Winter wrote, “During Paul’s time, his missionary band specifically nourished the churches—a most significant symbiosis.”[1] What is “symbiosis?” It is “the intimate living together of two dissimilar organisms in a mutually beneficial relationship.”[2] That is, Paul and Barnabas and other missionary bands (Prisca and Aquila) planted churches among the Gentiles. They appointed church elders and taught them that “the kingdom of God is entered through hardships” (Acts 14:21-23). Winter compared local churches and mobile missionaries teams to the warp and the woof of a fabric:
Just as it is impossible to make cloth without threads going both crosswise and lengthwise, it is crucially important to regard these two structures working together as the warp and the woof of the fabric, the fabric being the Christian movement—the people of God, the ecclesia of the New Testament, the church of Jesus Christ. Therefore, to make either of the two structures central and the other secondary, as the term parachurch seems to do, is probably unwise. The two are indeed interdependent and the evidences of history do not allow us to understand either of them as complete without the other. As in the Roman tradition, their relationship is at least potentially a beneficial symbiosis. The problem is that within Protestantism today the tension between the two is as great as or greater than ever before.[3]
Winter admires what he called “the enviable Roman Catholic synthesis.” That is, the Catholic church has validated both kinds of structures—local churches and mission agencies—in a way that has so far seemed unattainable in the Protestant way of thinking. Hence, a symbiotic relationship between Protestant churches and Protestant mission agencies is a desirable but as yet unrealized achievement. But we live in hope. Tomorrow may be the day.
[1] Ralph D. Winter, “The Two Structures of God’s Redemptive Mission,” Missiology 2, no. 1 (1974).
[2] Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 10th ed. (Springfield, MA: Merriam-Webster, 1997). s.v. “Symbiosis.”
[3] Ralph D. Winter, “Protestant Mission Societies and the ‘Other Protestant Schism’,” in American Denominational Organization (Pasadena: William Carey Library, 1980).


I am working on the “Gospel to the Oneida” (Remmber Kirkland?). There are a lot of moving parts to this complex story, but the first part is the story of a Mohawk captive, Rebecca Kellogg Ashley (1695–1757) who spends 24 years in a Jesuit taught, Catholic, Mohawk village, who returns to Massachusetts and ends up arguing theology with Johnathan Edwards and David Brainard and influencing Elihu Spencer, and She fundamentally reshaped his missionary strategy, altered his preaching style, and served as his primary intellectual window into the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) mind. Oh what a story!It will take 9 major, wild characters to tell the story.
It is new information for me that Ralph Winter held the Catholic church in high regard and appreciated its missions mindedness. I shouldn’t have been surprised, however, because Ralph was always looking for where the life of our Lord was being manifested, and he went beyond traditional views to experience that. In the 1970s there was an outpouring of God’s Spirit in Southern California that impacted both traditional protestant and Catholic clergy and churches. Christians of different persuasions opened up their churches and hearts in finding common bonds and much beauty in worshipping with fellow Christians and being moved in experiencing God’s presence with fresh blessings of His mercy and grace.